Critics’ Choice Judging
Be sure to join us at the Town Square stage on Sunday at 4:00pm for the Critics’ Choice Award Ceremony!
2026 Celebrity Judges
-

Emcee: Tim Shepardson
Owner of Rocks Bar Group. Also he’s tall.
-

Brigham Avery is the stylish and engaging host of Hollywood & Ivy, blending entertainment, pop culture, and celebrity conversation with a polished on-air presence. Known for his personable interviewing style, he brings both charm and insider flair to every segment.
-

Howard Buckner is a passionate BBQ enthusiast celebrated for his love of smoked meats, grilling culture, and bringing people together through food. Whether judging, cooking, or talking barbecue, he’s known for sharing authentic flavor and enthusiasm with every crowd.
-

Muffy Fishbasket is a colorful Chicago personality recognized for bringing humor, charisma, and larger-than-life energy to events and appearances around the city. With a memorable name and playful presence, Muffy has become a familiar face in local entertainment circles.
-
Pascal Ibgui, better known to fans as Pascal from The Golden Bachelor, won viewers over with his charisma, confidence, and fun-loving personality. His standout presence on the hit reality series made him a fan favorite among Bachelor Nation audiences.
-

John Moug is the energetic co-host of Moug & Karla Mornings on B96, known for his quick wit, relatable humor, and strong connection with Chicago listeners. His upbeat personality and entertainment-driven style help keep the city laughing through the morning commute.
Congrats to our 2025 Critics’ Choice Winner Armadillo’s BBQ!